63 Comments
User's avatar
User's avatar
Comment removed
Nov 28, 2025
Comment removed
Fraser Barnes's avatar

I’m glad to see comments that support the F-35. I believe the arguments here cover most of what I’d say in its defence, and in defence of the fighter pilots who we ask to fly them. I’d just like to add that the missile carrying bombers that challenge our airspace are now being escorted by fighters and the formations have been joint Russian and Chinese formations. Fighters we can expect to provide that escort will soon be Gen 5 capable: the Su-57, J-20, J-35 and J-36. So we must also be looking at a future Gen 6 fighter, one that is non U.S. and would allow us to learn on the way with the intent of making significant contributions to development and capability.

But I would like to add that I believe there is a role for the SAAB Gripen in our current context. Not as a front line fighter, but as a combat support fleet where it would fulfil the roles of Fighter Lead-In-Trainer (FLIT), adversary air (ADAIR) and air demonstration. I hope the readers understand the concept of FLIT, the advanced training our pilots take before graduating to the qualification course for the front line fighter. ADAIR is provided by Top Aces, a commercial “Red Air” company based in Quebec which started under the CAF’s Contracted Air Training contract, evolving into the world’s largest ADAIR service provider in the world. It has expanded to provide the USAF with F-16s acquired from the Israeli Air Force, modified with open architecture avionics and an AESA radar. Finally, there is a need to replace the Tutor flown by the Snowbird air demonstration team. Having a fighter in that role is a better recruiting tool than that of a training aircraft. I would even suggest that Top Aces would be the best beneficiary of the common fleet maintenance contract, given their experience with the F-16. These three roles plus the opportunity to produce 100-150 Gripens for the Ukrainian Air Force would be an excellent foundation for developing a combat fighter capability.

Peter Kuhn's avatar

I'm curious why we couldn't use the Gripen as a similar (albeit smaller) version of the US F-15EX "missile truck". Equip the Gripens with long range Meteor missiles supported by F-35s with their stealth and ability to manage the battle space. I don't believe the F-35 is certified for the Meteor yet. I've always thought the Gripen and F-35 would work well together.

Fraser Barnes's avatar

A reasonable question Peter. Along the lines of the Hurricane taking on the bombers while the Spits tackled the fighters. But the jury is out on that, at least at the unclassified level. In Alaska the U.S. has the opportunity for F-35s and F-16s to work together. My gut feel is that it would add to the workload of the F-35 lead. Perhaps some AI would need to be added to help out, especially since the F-35 is a single seater. Baby sitting a flight of Gripens at the point of engagement is problematic, not something I’d want to use as a base tactic. There are other inputs as well, that we don’t know how they contribute to the big picture: satellite, AEW, and OTHR data. All good, but the data needs to be managed and presented so that the aircrew aren’t overloaded. In air combat, decisions need to be made quickly. Adding more data to manage can make the whole system more vulnerable to the effects of EW too at just the wrong time.

User's avatar
Comment removed
Nov 28, 2025
Comment removed
Cameron Fraser's avatar

We have been participating in building aircraft since before WW II, and had a major increase in capacity during that war. Today our aerospace industry is the fifth largest in the world, so we punch well above our weight, but you are right in that it's not around combat aircraft. Here's the catch. Such development takes decades... all of the fighters currently in production today began as projects in the 1980s and 90s... and all of them are products of international partnerships (to a greater or lesser extent). The only countries that go it alone on fighter development are those with limited or no options for partnerships, like Russia.

Murray Beare's avatar

The best review of the ongoing debate yet. I am on the side of the pilots who eventually have to fly and perhaps die. A jet that reduces the probability of the latter is my choice. As an army guy,my wish is that the industrial benefits argument does not outweigh the operational effectiveness. This argument has left the Army in a state that is ineffective. Iltis jeeps, MLVWs, no tracked vehicles with tactical mobility, protection and firepower better than what the enemy has - and so on. Thankfully HIMARS is coming. No issue with insisting that we build out the industrial base with Canadian repair and overhaul facilities once the critical shortfalls (and there are many )are adressed.

Dave Hall's avatar

I am curious about the roles the CAF is expected to play and what that implies for procurement.

I have little doubt that the F35 will be the best plane for air to air conflict with the best Chinese or Russian fighters. Has the CAF faced that task since Korea? Are their likely scenarios where we would be doing that in the future?

I understand the Gripen's advantages are in easier use in the Arctic, use of shorter runways and less complex and less expensive maintainance requirements. Other than the cost issue, are these advantages important to roles the CAF has played? Are they relevant to Likely future roles?

Experts often, understandably, want the very best tool possible. But that can expensive luxury for the actual tasks at hand.

Cameron Fraser's avatar

Our Air Force didn't have a role during the Korean war, beyond transporting troops to and from, and some fighter pilots sent to America units on exchange postings. We were tasked with some air to air roles during the first Gulf War, but by the time those assignments roled around the threat was essentially gone. That being said, given our role in NORAD, or even just defending Canadian airspace if you want to downplay the alliance, maintaining an air to air capability is an absolute necessity.

Cameron Fraser's avatar

Addendum: We've also been tasked with air to air roles recently in Latvia.

Jack granatstein's avatar

There are possibilities of Russian or chinese attempts to grab parts of the Cdn Arctic in which case aircraft might be involved. Russian bombers continue to test NORAD. We need something much better than CF18s or Gripens.

Cameron Fraser's avatar

Joly's argument about industrial benefits seems to ignore a significant point. I suspect whatever benefits would stem from assembling Gripens in Canada would be limited to those we buy ourselves, (although I will concede we could get some work from other sales to places like Ukraine...maybe). On the other hand, we help build every single F-35... nearly 1,300 so far, with another 1,800 projected. That benefit measures in the billions, and may well exceed the intial acquisition costs of the F-35.

Michael Parker's avatar

Potentially an important point from a long-term total economic benefit to the Canadian defence industrial base perspective, with the added twist that Canada might gain some geopolitical leverage by withholding its F-35 contributions.

Bill Mac's avatar

We can continue to support the F35 program and participate to the same degree. The Gripen offer is due to SAAB's need to scale up well beyond a potential Canadian order and the inability to do that in Sweden. If not Canada they will find another partner. They have said that "of course" their offer of a partnership on production is premised on their being a Canadian order but it would not be for Canadian planes only.

Cameron Fraser's avatar

The small catch is that there has to be other orders for there to be more for Canada to produce. Beyond the 150 for Ukraine the only other order is for 24 for Peru. That's not a lot of airplanes, and I would hesitate to describe it as "well beyond a potential Canadian order". It's also not clear a Canadian facility would be running in time to contribute to either order

Bill Mac's avatar

Yeah. Im already out of my depth. Just challenging what I feel to be some obvious unanswered questions and putting arguments out there only because I haven't seen them properly addressed in the common conversation.

My assumption with the potential production in Canada (and likely all of it) is that without the real details (where the devil resides) we're all just shooting in the dark.

My main hope is that we don't (again) put all of our precious eggs in one proven to be risky basket.

Hugh McLean's avatar

Saab has been quite candid in admitting they need help in meeting their growing sales backlog. I believe they currently produce about two dozen planes a year in Sweden. If the Ukraine deal alone goes through . . .

Cameron Fraser's avatar

That's a considerable "if", and if it doesn't, the only other existing order is equivalent to a single year of production.

Bob Miller's avatar

Afraid I am a mixed fleet proponent. I know the F35 is a more capable plane but the ongoing costs & uncertainty, the lack of a block 4 version anytime soon (the one we ordered), the aircraft availability rate is still only 50% (US GAO office). The jobs thing may be a wash if Trump hadn’t said after the current contracts expire he wants those jobs back in the US. Lastly if so many of the ex RCAF current proponents hadn’t gone to work for Lockhead Martin in some capacity. It feels like high stakes influencers are working on both sides of the fence.

Michael Parker's avatar

Excellent analysis, yet again, thank you. To avoid the potential mixed-fleet problem, could Canada not simply sell the F-35s it is committed to buy to another country?

Cameron Fraser's avatar

Not without American permission. Security around the airplane is pretty strict. It's why Turkey was kicked out of the program when they bought Russian anti-aircraft systems.

Michael Parker's avatar

All that is understood. I was really suggesting sale to another F-35 country.

Cameron Fraser's avatar

While there might be fewer hurdles, even that is still subject to American permissions. It is also dependent on 1) a willing buyer and 2) the US not blocking such a sale out of spite and as punishment.

There is (at least) one other thing to consider. The first F-35s get delivered next year. How long will it be until Gripens can be delivered?

Glen's avatar

For clarity the first eight F35s get delivered to Luke AFB as part of the training pool, where all pilot and maintainer training will take place. Additionally they will not be Tr3/Block4 aircraft as originally bid - a slight problem from a contracting porblem - as the Tr3/Blk4 update is behin schedule by as much as 5 years.

David Johnson's avatar

Thanks for this piece, Philippe. I wonder if you could elaborate a bit more on Canada's "contributing to operations overseas" mission. Presumably this means both meeting Canada's commitments to NATO and to "other expeditionary war-fighting" in concert with the United States.

From a strategic perspective, how critical is the second part of that capability for Canada? Does this mean assisting the U.S., say, in toppling the government of Venezuela? Assisting the U.S. in supporting Israel in conflict with Iran? Assisting the U.S. in defending a non-democratic-but-oil-rich state in Southwest Asia from attack?

Presumably it might also mean joining the U.S. in defence of Taiwan or South Korea or Japan or Australia, but when it comes to air warfare would Canadian participation in such a mission be crucial for its success, or would it be, rather, a matter of Canada making a mostly symbolic contribution?

The planned fleet of 88 F35s must be sized to allow Canada to meet all of these commitments: to North American defence, to NATO, and to these other "operations overseas." It also seems reasonable to assume that the planned F35 fleet is sized to allow Canada to accomplish all of these missions simultaneously, that we would not, for example, temporarily reduce our commitment to North America defence, or to NATO, in order to support an expeditionary war-fighting mission alongside the U.S.

Does that mean there might be "excess" capacity in the fleet of 88 F35s, should Canada decide that expeditionary war-fighting with the U.S., other than in the North Atlantic region, is not a strategic necessity?

Neal Rauhauser's avatar

If you listen to Peter Zeihan he's predicting the U.S. military will get dumbed down, which Kegsbreath is driving at a fast trot, and we'll get more adventuresome. See the southern Caribbean for examples of that. We'll give up on globalism, then the average American will understand, but only after the supply chain pummels them into a teachable condition, and our military will become a sort of combined arms gunboat diplomacy operation. Who knows, maybe we'll even be issuing letters of marque before long.

Jim Cox's avatar

I too think this is the best review of the issue to date. However, my one hope is that future reviews of this calibre can include the issue "at the other end of the table"... that being, what do we need to prevail in the war for Canada. Will we fight? What do we need to fight with? In the aerospace warfighting domain, fighter aircraft is only one (albeit a major one) of the capabilities required. Both planes are good and will be effective in a fight, but the F-35 is 'better' and probably necessary for true air superiority/dominance over Canada. However, the F-35 need not be used for all classes of fighting. A second fleet of proven fighters provides flexibility. Gripens would be handy to fill our periodic commitments to NATO air operations in Europe. The F-35 could focus on our role in NORAD and Canadian sovereignty in the Arctic region. In a pinch, both could support the other.

However, hanging over all of this is the wartime issue of how do we get more fighter aircraft quickly, in the face of combat attrition? Initial acquisitions of a capability need to be built with attrition and sustainment in mind.

My overall point here is that we might commence this conversation by deciding what is needed to prevail in the war for Canada, and then figure out how to get it, rather than starting with what we think is affordable and figure out what it can do.

Dave Beed's avatar

Here is a hypothetical question. Would all of the passionate newly educated Canadian air power experts be giving as much of a hoot if Mrs Harris was President?

Neal Rauhauser's avatar

Air power nerds gonna air power, but if Harris were in the Oval Office, the U.S. would be slowly unwinding as an imperial power, rather than showing the signs of imminent collapse. The conversation would be the same, but the intensity would be a fraction of what it is. As Churchill so famously said "we are entering a time of consequences".

Bill Mac's avatar

Its an interesting hypothetical.

Surely, we'd still be a free country and so, free to have opinions - even if we aren't experts. Just like most of us aren't experts in ANY of the big decisions government has to make on our behalf. Most are not engineers, economists, virologists, or even public administration experts. Its never stopped us from having opinions and discussing these things. It's our money, it's our security, and it's our country.

So, the "expert" slight, I think, is clearly misplaced.

To the question; would this many people be this engaged if we hadn't lost all faith in the US as a partner and ally? I can't say for sure but...

Logic suggests "no."

Peter Frood's avatar

Really appreciate your balanced framing of the issues. Whatever happens, it will be a messy decision. I note your comments about strategic investments in drones and other autonomous equipment. Thé Ukrain is a lesson in the changing nature of war. We should work with the Europeans on these projects. I hope you write about these issues in the future.

Bill E. Featherstone, M.A.'s avatar

Some interesting things to consider here for all the options you have described. I think there’s more that needs to be fleshed out here, so I’ll reserve judgement for now!

Derrin Urban's avatar

I am also a mixed fleet guy (as I commented in the "It Depends" article). As Thom mentioned, There is not a lot of mention of availability in these discussions. It is nice to have an amazing airplane like the F-35, but if it is a hangar queen always waiting on maintenance or spare parts, it is an expensive paperweight. The other thing not mentioned and I am sure I already know the answer, is can the F-35 use the 4 NORAD Forward Operating Location (FOL) airfields. The F-35s do not seem like they would be capable of using them. They have hangers for a few CF-18s at each base. They would probably not be able to be used by the F-35s. The Gripens I imagine could use them. The 4 FOLs are located at Yellowknife, Inuvik, Rankin Inlet and Iqaluit.

Operating patrols out of the FOLs would be more ideally suited to Gripens. My guess is if we used F-35s for daily patrols, we would have to also run daily air tankers to keep them fueled rather than always returning to Cold Lak for fuel.

Cameron Fraser's avatar

Given the range limitations, nobody "patrols" with fighter aircraft, with the possible exceptions of BARCAP operations or enforcing no-fly zones. Both presume active and ongoing hostilities. Patrolling is what the new P-8s and UCAVs will be for.

As to the FOLs, upgrading and expanding them would likely be a useful thing to do in the name of sovereignty anyway.

We have, of course, recently purchased a fleet of Multi-Role Tanker/Transport aircraft specifically to support the new fighter fleet, whatever it might be. (Although they have probe and drogue refueling, as used by the F-18 and the Gripen, they are also specifically equipped with the boom refueling system required by the F-35).

Derrin Urban's avatar

true enough. The majority of patrol will be P-8s for marine and some sort of AEW&C for air. The FOLs were already upgraded and modernized to support CF-18s. The cost to upgrade them to F-35 standards would be unrealistic. Perhaps they will just become airports to resupply the tankers. Realistically, the F-35 will land only at Bagotville and Cold Lake.

I still think the F-35 is a shiny paperweight. It is a far too fragile aircraft for prolonged use. Glass Cannon.

Cameron Fraser's avatar

And your evidence for that is...?

Derrin Urban's avatar

Which part the FOLs or the Glass Cannon part. They were originally modernized in the 90s. However, I was reading on the gov of canada website and actually found that a 2022 program has earmarked part of a $3B appropriation for Modernization of the FOLs again. It is only at working up concepts/needs phase so no information.

The glass cannon part is my opinion due to the horrible availability rates. If even the americans can't keep more than 40%-50% flying, how in the hell to does anyone think we will do better. Great plane, way to many maintenance and repair problems. Plus Block 4 models are at least 5 years behind schedule.

Craig Smith's avatar

Here is my plan, Mark, David, Stephen, Melanie please feel free to use :-)

With the increase in defence spending increase the fighter fleet to be in the range of 138 (I choose this number as 138 CF-18 planes were originally built)

The mix as of 2025 is 88 F35 and 50 Gripen but is subject to change

Divide the F35 into tranches, implementation has to be phased anyways but this gives us the opportunity to maintain some leverage to make sure our industry stays involved and depending on the Gripen the opportunity to change the mix

IMMEDIATELY sign the partnership with Saab, shovels in the ground by spring. Build Globaleye in Toronto and Gripen in Montreal with a big assist from IMP in Halifax (they will need work with the loss of in service support and this will allow them to retain skilled people https://canadiandefencereview.com/in-service-support-imp-turbulence-ahead-navigating-the-gap-between-fleets/

As part of the Saab partnership work with them on their 6th generation project. The Gripen has already been flown by AI (google Helsing Gripen) and we can contribute our expertise in AI and drones. This I believe is the only way to get into this ecosystem as the other projects - GCAP and FCAS - are pretty set with partners and there isn’t a lot of work left. As France and Germany are on the outs in the FCAS project (similar to what France did with leaving the Eurofighter program they are likely to go alone) invite Germany to join this Swedish/Canadian project.

Bill Mac's avatar

The big problem is a typical problem. We don't really know what we will use the fighter jets for. We have a risk analysis that creates various scenarios but we have no idea which, if any, will materialize. Recognizing that part of the argument is being able to face a given scenario effectively can reduce the chances of it happening. That said.

1. It is NOT military as usual in the US. Things are eroding everywhere and the “early” signs there I’m probably missing but the ones I do see are…

They are using the military to conduct extra judicial killing in an open and braggadocios manner. Even killing helpless individuals clinging to the remains of the boat they just blew up. There is no scenario where this is not a war crime. We think they’re going to do this with their military and all the other rule books they’re throwing out, including around how they deal with Canada, but somehow, they’re going to carve out this little niche that is their military relationship with Canada and maintain it pristine… because, why? Fantastical thinking is what it looks like to me.

They are using their military for leverage all over the place for various self-interests, with the easiest current example being Ukraine. In normal times it would be embarrassing for them – beyond all the other more flavourful adjectives that duly apply.

2. If the Gripen does the job, then the technical argument has changed.

A BMW 760Li Sterling edition performs much better in just about every way to a Subaru Outback but does that mean we need that EXTRA capability? Or that we don't need the Outback.

3. On the economics and feasibility of a mixed fleet.

So few discuss the offsets. We hear that it’s more expensive to have a mixed fleet and we hear that the Gripen is a fraction of the cost. These things clearly have some amount of offset. Why are these two arguments always presented separately? At which point in a mixed fleet scenario does the overall risk and cost start to decline? Why spend so much more money? What if we bought 50 F35s and 50 Gripens. 14% more planes but because of the better availability of the Gripens 50% more available aircraft. Might it be the same overall cost or a reasonable amount more?

4. On the risk of a supply chain conflict and the US repatriating what is currently external work. The immediate self-harm to them may be a mitigating safeguard but it's still in the risk column. And one with a relatively high likelihood and impact.

John Quiggin's avatar

"The various happenings at the political level aren’t affecting relations at the official and military level."

Where do these levels start? Hegseth has sacked most of the senior military hierarchy. He's only just started replacing them but it's a safe bit that the new guys will be MAGA-aligned.

Of course, routine contacts, joint exercises and so on will go on, until they don't, but that's meaningless. When the US brass get the order to invade Canada and commit war crimes, they'll do it. Trumo has been 100 per cent lear on tbis